Elena Aguilar leads a team of instructional and leadership coaches in the Oakland (CA) Unified School District and is the author of the new book from Wiley/Jossey-Bass, The Art of Coaching: Effective Strategies for School Transformation. She also writes The Art of Coaching Teachers blog for Education Week Teacher.

In this interview with ABPC editor and consultant John Norton, Aguilar talks about her own experiences as a teacher and coach and share her views about how partnering with teachers (and principals) to improve practice can lead to positive whole-school change.

1. Tell us something about your own teaching career, milestones, and how you transitioned from teacher to teaching and leadership coach.

I began teaching in 1994 in rural Salinas, California. I taught high school students who were recent immigrants, migrant workers, and English learners. A year later I moved to Oakland, California, where I taught bilingual elementary school and then middle school humanities. In 2001, I helped start ASCEND, a small K-8 public school. This was a transformative experience as I saw what was possible when a small group of experienced and committed educators designed a school and were given autonomy to decide on curriculum, instructional programming, hiring, and much more.

ASCEND was committed to project-based learning, arts integration, partnerships with families and community, and social and emotional learning. Teachers participated in rigorous, inquiry-based professional development. I wasn’t a new teacher when we started ASCEND, but because of the opportunities I had—which included working with a brilliant coach—I felt like I became a “real teacher.” I was certainly a much more effective and satisfied teacher than I’d ever been. It was an ideal context in which to discover who I was as a teacher and leader.

I loved being a middle school teacher, but saw so many others struggling. In part because of a commitment to seeing all students learn, I became a coach. I coached part time at ASCEND for three years before taking a full time, instructional coaching position at another Oakland middle school. Instructional coaching led me into leadership coaching—I recognized that principal development needed to go hand in hand with teacher development, and that there were limits to instructional transformation when administrators weren’t engaged in their own learning and growth process.

I now lead a team of instructional and leadership coaches who work with four of our most struggling middle schools in Oakland. These schools are receiving the federal School Improvement Grant, and we have built a robust coaching program which is tightly aligned to the schools’ goals and professional development plans. I continue to coach two principals and a teacher-leader.

2. In your introduction to your new book The Art of Coaching (Jossey Bass, 2013), you recall the familiar advice to would-be authors to “write the book you want to read” — and go on to say that “this is the book I wanted to read as a new, struggling coach.” How does your book support the new-coach audience? Are there other audiences?

Although it’s been some years since I was a new coach, I remember those days vividly. The domain of coaching seemed huge and nebulous. I sensed there was so much to know and learn, but had no idea how to start or what the specifics were that I should learn. What I attempt to do in my book is deconstruct this domain into manageable and replicable action steps.

The Art of Coaching starts with suggestions on how to get your coaching-self ready for this work—how to reflect on your beliefs, values, and vision. Then it moves into some of ways you can build trust with new “coachees,” how you can get to know them and their contexts. Coaching happens in conversations, so there are a lot of resources in the book to support powerful coaching conversations—how to listen and ask questions, how to ask different kinds of questions for different purposes, how to manage and guide conversations and respond to whatever surfaces.

My book also suggests ways that coaches can organize their work, strategically plan their coaching, and reflect on their work. I remembered being a new coach and just wanting tools, sentence stems, prompts to use with clients—and I have included many of these in my book. But as a new coach, I also wanted to be inspired and be reminded of the bigger picture for why I was doing what I was doing. I’ve attempted to respond to that need by including inspirational quotes, suggestions for practices that help us reconnect to something bigger, and my own reflective stories about coaching. I hope that this book offers a solid starting point for a new coach working in schools.

I am also convinced that coaches of all levels of experience will find something useful in this book. Coaching is still a relatively new field. There’s so much more to learn and understand and say about coaching and by reading other people’s material and engaging in conversation with each other we’ll dig deeper into the potential in coaching. I hope that this book starts many conversations within the coaching world.

I also believe that administrators will find useful strategies in my book. Principals often use coaching approaches with their teachers, and there are specific areas highlighted for administrators that might be helpful. And I believe that teacher leaders will find resources and tools in the book for developing collaborative practices with colleagues. Teachers are often asked to give each other feedback or mentor each other. I think there are a lot of suggestions in The Art of Coaching for how we can more effectively work with each other in schools.

3. In The Art of Coaching, you describe your model and approach to working with teachers and schools as “transformational.” What are the core elements of your model and how does it differ from other approaches to school-based coaching we might be familiar with?

Transformational coaching explores and addresses an educator’s behaviors, beliefs, and ways of being. When working with a teacher, I coach towards shifts in instructional practices—I want to help them do things differently, and I aspire to expand reflective capacities—I want to help them think about what they’re doing differently. Furthermore, I want to help the person being coached to explore his or her underlying belief systems that are at play in decision-making, communication, and so on.

I strive to increase awareness of our beliefs systems because I believe this leads to permanent change in practice. Sometimes we have beliefs that are silently serving us, but sometimes we may not be conscious that our underlying beliefs are negatively impacting our work. Transformational coaching intends to surface and name those connections and allow the coachee to decide what to do about them.

Transformational coaching also attends to ways of being. For example, when working with a principal who is preparing for a hard conversation with a teacher, I repeatedly ask, “Who do you want to be in this situation? How do you want your teacher to experience you? How do you want to show up in this conversation?” I probe into these deep and existential places because I know that there’s a tight connection between the words we use and who we’re being.

Coaching in this way pulls people back to core values and deep commitments, and often back into a place of compassion and kindness. This kind of coaching also opens up the terrain of emotions and resilience. Working in public schools is very hard and there are few opportunities within our work day or week to attend to our emotions. So if you coach a teacher at the end of a long day, it’s almost inevitable that he or she might arrive for the coaching session experiencing emotions.

Sometimes these emotions can get in the way of being able to dig into planning a lesson or analyzing student work, so a transformational coach learns strategies to help a coachee manage the emotions that come up in our work. I think this is an essential component of the kind of coaching I practice—and it’s what makes it potentially transformational.

Most effective educators I’ve worked with have learned ways to manage the stress of working in school—those strategies have allowed them to stay in the profession long after others have left. In Oakland, where I’ve worked for 18 years, we lose about a third of our teachers every year. It’s an extremely challenging context. Incorporating coaching strategies which support teachers to process their emotional experiences is critical.

Another aspect of transformational coaching that distinguishes it from other coaching models that I am aware of is that transformational coaches are constantly engaged in their own transformation—of their own behaviors, beliefs and being. In the coaching program I lead in Oakland, my coaches spend one full day per week (20 percent of our time!) in our own professional learning community. In our PD we develop our practices, explore our beliefs, and attend to our personal transformation and ways of being—we’re always striving to cultivate ourselves as calm, grounded coaches who are aware of how we show up. We can’t practice transformational coaching without simultaneously engaging in our own transformation.

Finally, I’d say that transformational coaching aims at transforming individuals within a system (teachers, principals, etc.) and transforming the system itself. I practice a model of coaching which is very intentional about affecting system change. At every moment in coaching, we reflect on what elements of the current reality are embedded within larger systems, what access we have to shifting that system, and how we can examine and move both the part and whole.

4. In Alabama, the Instructional Partners Pilot project is advocating an approach to instructional coaching that builds on the big idea that the best coaching is facilitative and seeks to nurture or strengthen a collaborative professional learning culture in schools, rather than deliver expertise in a purely mentor/mentee structure. How does this fit with your own view of coaching?

One of my coaching-rules is a phrase coined by master coach Julio Olalla, “There is no coaching without trust.” I have spent a lot of time thinking about trust—how to develop it, measure it, assess it, maintain it, and build it across lines of gender, age, race and ethnicity, experience and background and so on. I believe the only way to build trust and cross these lines is by facilitative coaching—by letting the coachee take the lead and direct the learning, and by building on what the coachee already knows.

Even when working with brand new teachers, I think there’s a way we can effectively coach in this way. I have seen very few successful directive coaching programs. I have also spent a lot of time understanding the particulars and needs of adult learners, and I keep coming back to facilitative coaching as the starting point. It’s just the way that adults need to engage in learning.

That isn’t to say, however, that sometimes when working with brand new, 21 year old teachers, we can’t take a directive approach—there are moments when giving information, or making suggestions is necessary. But we always need to start from a facilitative stance. It’s essential in building trust.

5. Might individual school conditions influence or determine the best coaching model? And if you think so, how might coaching look different in schools with high or low SES populations, in urban, suburban and rural schools, schools with a lot of ethnic diversity, etc.?

This is an important question for us to consider when designing coaching models. I think an effective coaching program needs to be tailored to the current reality of a school site or district. Coaching programs are challenged when there’s a lack of alignment between a district’s vision or goals, a site’s vision or goals, and a teacher’s vision or goals.

In schools that are in early stages of development, this lack of alignment makes it hard for individuals to get clarity on what they should focus on in terms of improving their practice, or student learning, or instructional strategies. Resources (such as time) are often not aligned to priorities. Teachers get mixed messages. Coaching can be frustrating for all involved when there’s a lack of alignment and a lack of clarity about priorities. This leads to lack of agreed expectations, assumptions about what coaching should be able to do, and so on.

So I’d say a coaching model needs to name the conditions necessary in order for it to be effective. What needs to be in place and be true for coaching to have an impact on teacher practice and student learning? We need to understand the way that systems (or the absence of systems) impacts coaching, and then we can tailor our model, or be very transparent about what coaching might be able to accomplish.

In order to be effective, coaches need both skill and expertise in the domain of coaching and a content base which allows them to understand the teacher’s reality. In order for a coach to best support, let’s say, a new high school teacher working with a population of recent immigrants, the coach will need to anticipate the challenges the teacher might encounter (language, cultural, communication, etc.) and have some knowledge of how to navigate those in the classroom. While working from a facilitative stance, the coach may need to guide the teacher into addressing issues in a certain order.

Or, for example, if a coach is working with a science teacher on collaborative inquiry, but the teacher doesn’t have strong classroom management routines, then the coach needs to guide the teacher into addressing that foundational element first.

6. You’ve worked in a coaching role with principals as well as teachers. How is this work different? Are principals receptive to a coach who has not herself been a principal? How do you earn their trust?

I think in some ways it’s easier for me to coach administrators than teachers because I’ve never been a site administrator. When I first start working with principals, I always say, “I’ve never been a principal. I don’t know what I’d do in your shoes. I can’t give you advice or direction, but I can help you think through your work—I can coach you.” This often makes administrators feel more relaxed. It levels the playing field—I’m not going to tell you what to do, I’m not here to judge you, I recognize that there are things you know that I don’t.

I also assure them that I have spent many years learning about effective leadership, school systems, teaching and instruction, professional development and so on, and that that knowledge base will help me in my work with them. But I often find that because I haven’t held the same role, they feel more at ease. It helps to navigate the dynamic that’s often present between a coach and coachee—of one person being the expert and the other the learner.

I tell them, “I’m a thought partner, someone who can help you consider decisions, reflect on your actions, analyze data, explore who you want to be, and so on, but I can’t tell you what to do.” They like that—no one wants someone who’s going to tell them what to do.

In the places where I’ve worked, principals receive very little support or professional development and many are eager for coaching. They often express feeling isolated and lonely in their work, and over and over they tell me, “You’re the only one I can really talk to.” I’ve found that a significant amount of my coaching is on building emotional resilience, emotional intelligence, and communication skills.

I have a lot of empathy for principals. It seems like incredibly difficult, consuming work, and I rarely see principals who are well-prepared for the role. I share these perceptions with principals, and I find authentic ways to recognize and validate what they do and have done. I’ve found it easier than I expected to earn their trust. I also always honor my word that our work is confidential, and I think they quickly experience me as someone who keeps that word, who will help them strengthen their leadership capacities, and who will help them improve the outcomes and experiences for their students.

They also quickly learn that I’m not all about being warm and fuzzy and validating—I get permission from them to push them, and then I do so—hard and relentlessly. I push and push and push them to be the leaders they want to be, and that their site and community needs them to be. I don’t let up. They appreciate this and trust me more because of it.

There are some ways in which coaching principals is different than teachers (I could write another book on it) and there are many ways in which it is similar. Some colleagues and I wrote about this in an Educational Leadership article, “Support Principals, Transform Schools.”

7. Your statement early in your book that “I am not yet fully the artful coach I aspire to be” speaks to the hunger to improve that marks the true professional. What are some aspects of your own coaching practice that might need improvement?

There are so many aspects of my coaching practice that I want to improve, just about all of them. I still feel like I’ve only scratched the surface of what coaching can be, and I’ve never been more eager to dig deeper into coaching.

Recently I have been really thinking about how to assess a coachee’s zone of proximal development (ZPD) and how to work on the edge of it. I’m surprised at how often I discover, months after working with someone, that I’d inaccurately assessed what he or she knew or could do. I slap myself on the forehead and realize that my coaching wasn’t working because it was directed at the wrong spot.

I’m also working on being intentional and strategic in every coaching conversation—I want to find the balance between honoring where my coachee is, allowing him or her to reflect, and then moving him or her to new actions. I also want to incorporate more modeling. I’ve been apprehensive about modeling for teachers or administrators, but because I work with so many novices, I’m realizing that I need to do it more.

I recently did some guest teaching in a new teacher’s classroom, and she later reflected that it was the one of the most useful learning opportunities she’d had all year. New teachers need to see what it looks like to review a daily learning target with their students just as new administrators need to see an experienced facilitator lead a difficult staff meeting or a coach give a teacher feedback that shifts practice.

I also want to continue articulating the requisite conditions for coaching to be effective. (One place I do that is in my blog for Education Week Teacher.) And I want to help create those conditions where they’re missing. We need to design systems in which coaching can fulfill its potential. Another area that I’d love to spend more time exploring is how we can make the impact of coaching explicit: What data can we gather that shows a correlation between a coach’s work with a teacher and an increase in student learning? I want to continue to make our work public and visible, in part because I want to prove that coaching works!

Finally, I’m always striving to be more grounded, to listen on a deep level, and to be more compassionate and accepting. That’s going to be a life-long journey, and it’s one I’m thrilled to be on.