Professional capital is about collective responsibility, not individual autonomy; about scientific evidence as well as personal judgment; about being open to one’s clients rather than standing on a pedestal above them; and ultimately about being touch on those colleagues who, after every effort and encouragement, fall short of their professional mission and let their peers as well as their students down.
So begins the book Professional Capital: Transforming Teaching in Every School by Andy Hargreaves and Michael Fullan (Teachers College Press, 2012).
Fullan and Hargreaves have long been colleagues and have authored many books and papers together. Last week, some of us in Alabama were fortunate enough to spend a morning listening and learning from Michael Fullan when he spoke in Huntsville. While he focused primarily on his views about professional capital, his remarks also touched on technology as a disruptive innovation, and on the role of leadership.
What is professional capital and why is it important?
Fullan and Hargreaves posit that professional capital is comprised of both human capital –individual teacher and school leader knowledge and skills – and social capital, which Fullan defines as the talent of the whole group.
Expanding on his views of social capital at last week’s presentation, Fullan referred to a study conducted by Carrie Leana, a business professor at the University of Pittsburgh, who studied more than 1,000 fourth and fifth grade teachers in 130 schools in New York to measure the impact of professional capital. Leana’s human capital research measured “individual teacher qualifications, experience, and ability to teach.” She measured social capital “in terms of the frequency and focus of conversations and interactions with peers that centered on instruction, and was based on feelings of trust and closeness between teachers.” (p. 3)
Leana’s findings? Schools with higher social capital did better. Schools with lots of human and social capital did best. Notably, however, she found that in schools with a teacher with low human capital, if that teacher was in a school with high social capital, that teacher got better!
Fullan’s important point: Social capital enhances human capital in a powerful way. “If you concentrate your efforts on increasing individual talent,” he proposes, “you will have a devil of a job producing greater social capital. There is just no mechanism or motivation to bring all that talent together. The reverse is not true. High social capital does generate increased human capital. Individuals get confidence, learning, and feedback from having the right kind of people and the right kinds of interactions and relationships around them.” (p. 4)
To better explain social capital, Fullan coined a phrase – systemness – which he described as the sense or degree of identification that a person has to a system. As an example, he pointed to teachers who consider all students in their school as their responsibility instead just the students they teach daily. “Systemness,” Fullan noted, also refers to networks where participants feel allegiance and commitment to other schools in the network – and where there is a great sense of mutual allegiance to those working to better the whole system.
The value of systemness
We’re seeing Fullan’s systemness in action in our work in schools that promote and create vibrant communities of practice, often called professional learning communities. We’re also seeing this kind of collective capacity nurtured in schools involved in the Instructional Partner Pilot and among participants in the IP network.
And, what are the results of a high degree of systemness, according to Fullan? Greater focus and consistency, with sustained collective attention on behalf of improved practice. The collective action reinforces educational practice that gets results, and lots of people are “talking the walk, as they walk the talk.”
Fullan contends that “talking the walk” is powerful change behavior. Why? When people talk the walk, they are being vocal, reflective and transparent about their practice. People are able to go into schools where this is happening and see evidence of consistency; when they ask questions about effective instruction, they hear the same answers – and they are good answers. The result is better performance across the board.
Based on your understanding of social capital, what are you doing in your school to build that collective capacity so that everyone – teachers and students – get better at reflecting on what works for teaching and learning?