A few weeks ago I participated on a team at the Montgomery Education Foundation’s “Brain Brawl.” The event was a fundraiser for the MEF and for schools in Montgomery. Teams of five from companies, nonprofits, and education paid a $150 entry fee to participate in a night of trivia.
Driving to the multiplex, I reminded myself that I was pretty good at trivia. Then, I remembered my depressing “milestone” birthday earlier this fall and wondered whether most of the questions would be outside of my wheelhouse…like “bands from the 90’s.”
Fortunately, our team crossed generations with several millenials on it as well. So, we were in good shape, or so I thought. By the third round, however, we were hoping just to not come in last!
Some of the questions included:
• Give the first and last name of the man who survived a traumatic brain injury in 1948 when a steel rod was propelled into his brain (Phineas Gage).
• Or, how about “name five of the locations of the US Mint in 1946” (did you know that Dahlonega, GA was one of the locations?).
• Or, name the number of presidents who served as General in the US military. Our team confidently responded by writing down the number 5 (Washington, Jackson, Taylor, Grant, and Eisenhower). Wrong again! There are 12, and you can find the listing by Googling that question.
Fortunately, there were many teams who were much more successful than we were and fun was had by all. Most important, MEF and Montgomery schools benefitted from the event!
Reflecting on trivia and learning
As I drove home that evening, I started thinking about the relationship of the trivia questions to learning, particularly in light of Alabama’s new standards. As teachers design and plan lessons to engage students in higher-level content, it has become clear that many of the factoids that I had to memorize in school now can be easily accessed on Google or SIRI, leaving mental space to use those facts to think more deeply about their implications.
For example, the question about the U.S. Mints could be changed to a higher order question if we were asked to investigate and explain the reasons for the reduction in the number of US Mints from 1946 to today. Or, thinking about the question about the presidents who were also generals made me ponder why, during the early years of the USA, so many generals also served as president, when contemporary times only produced one.
These musings reminded me of why it is so hard to improve education across the board. Could it be because we all hold on to our own notions of what school “looks like?” If that’s the case, then – at least for me – I’d walk into school libraries expecting to see card catalogues, sets of World Book Encyclopedias and Encyclopedia Britannicas, while having lots of dimes in my pocket for Xeroxing copies from books that were in the Research Section and couldn’t be checked out.
Since I spend time throughout the year in schools, I know better, of course. Today, the only time I see a card catalogue case, it’s in the women’s bathroom to hold lipstick and other teacher provisions. And students of today, pointed to a shelf of books and a copy machine, would wonder why they can’t access needed materials on the Internet and perhaps send them to a printer.
Are we moving beyond memorization?
All this said, before you consider whether memorization is a thing of the past, let me introduce the thinking of Daniel Willingham, a cognitive scientist, professor, and author from the University of Virginia. He writes:
“In today’s world, is there a reason to memorize anything? You can find any factual information you need in seconds via the Internet including the definition of yegg. Then, too, things change so quickly that half of the information you commit to memory will be out-of-date in five years – or so the argument goes. Perhaps instead of learning facts it’s better to practice critical thinking, to have students work at evaluating all the information available on the Internet rather than trying to commit some small part of it to memory.
Willingham counters the argument this way:
“… The very processes that teachers care about the most – critical thinking processes such as reasoning and problem-solving – are intimately intertwined with factual knowledge that is stored in long-term memory (not just found in the environment).”
“… When we learn to think critically about, say, the start of the Second World War, it does not mean we can also think critically about a chess game or about the current situation in the Middle East or even about the start of the American Revolutionary War. Critical thinking processes are tied to background knowledge (although they become much less so when we become quite experienced…). The conclusion from this work in cognitive science is straightforward: we must ensure that students acquire background knowledge parallel with practicing critical thinking skills.” (2009, p. 21-22)
Willingham is also quoted in a recent Education Week blog — “For Reading, Knowledge Matters More Than Strategies, Some Experts Say” — along with other scholars, including Dr. Susan Neuman, professor of literacy education at New York University, who said: “Many teachers are teaching strategies—they’re teaching rereading, questioning, summarizing. But (what is important is) recognizing that comprehension is not a generic skill. It’s particular to that content area.”
Having it both ways
So there are some facts that we need to move to long-term memory as background knowledge: math and science facts and other important data that we frequently use. And, I’d argue that many of us need to know even more facts dealing with geography, government, and other important principles. (If you enjoy Jeopardy, think how often you use your background knowledge, not random fact recall, to analyze and make a good guess about a clue.)
Those who know me well know that I’m always searching for the “both-and” solution. Once again, my participation in the MEF trivia contest reminded me of a “both-and” scenario. A robust long-term memory full of important facts is necessary. But we also need to know what to do with those facts.
If we only value “knowing things” without applying them, we might answer questions in trivia contests, but end up lacking the type of critical thinking skills that we need to be agile, discerning citizens and productive workers in our ever-changing world.